The door creaked open.
A woman stood there, mid-thirties maybe, dark hair pulled into a low ponytail, eyes already glossy like she’d been crying on the drive over. She looked past Denise, straight at Billy.
And then at William.
Her hand flew to her mouth.
“Oh my God,” she whispered. “That’s him.”
William staggered back like he’d been hit.
“Mom,” he said slowly, dangerously, “who is this?”
Denise folded her arms, satisfied.
“This,” she said, “is Claire. The woman your wife forgot to mention.”
I felt my pulse roaring in my ears.
“I have never seen her in my life.”
Claire shook her head, tears spilling now.
“I didn’t know about you,” she said to William. “I swear. Denise found me through the DNA site. She said… she said my son might have a brother.”
I dropped into the nearest chair.
Denise sniffed.
“Well, the results were very clear. A 99.9% match. Billy is not related to my son.”
The words landed like broken glass.
Billy tugged at my sleeve.
“Mommy? Why is Grandma yelling?”
William turned on his mother, voice shaking with rage.
“You took my child’s DNA. Without consent. Without his parents. Do you have any idea what you’ve done?”
Denise waved him off.
“I did what you were too blind to do. I protected you. That boy isn’t yours.”
That’s when Claire spoke again, barely audible.
“There’s something wrong,” she said.
Everyone froze.
She pulled out her phone, hands trembling.
“The DNA company… they contacted me again. They said there was an error. A lab mix-up. They reran the test.”
Denise’s smile flickered.
“They said the child doesn’t match me,” Claire continued. “At all.”
Silence.
“They do,” she said, lifting her eyes to William, “match you.”
Denise laughed, sharp and brittle.
“That’s impossible.”
Claire shook her head.
“My son died four years ago. Stillborn. The hospital confirmed it.”
I stood up so fast my chair scraped loudly across the floor.
Denise went pale.
Claire’s voice broke.
“The company says Billy is genetically my son… and William’s.”
The room erupted.
“That’s insane,” William said. “That can’t be—”
I felt sick.
“Unless,” I whispered, staring at Denise, “someone switched babies.”
Denise backed away, shaking.
“You don’t know what you’re saying.”
But she was crying now.
And that’s when Billy walked over to William, climbed into his lap, and said softly:
“Daddy, why is Grandma scared?”
Denise collapsed into a chair.
“I just wanted to get rid of him,” she sobbed. “I never meant for the truth to come out.”
That night, the police were called.
Hospitals were contacted.
Lawyers followed.
We learned Denise had worked briefly as a volunteer at the maternity ward where Billy was born.
She had made a choice.
One she thought would stay buried forever.
But instead, it exposed everything.
Billy didn’t lose a family that night.
He gained the truth.
And Denise?
She lost us all.
